GUARDIANS OF THE BALLOT: CONSTITUTIONAL COURTS, ELECTORAL RIGHTS, AND THE COMPLAINT PATHWAY TO JUSTICE

Authors

  • Dayandini HP Ministry of National Development Planning/National Development Planning Agency Author
  • Fidelia Febi Valentika Universitas Diponegoro Author

Keywords:

constitutional complaint, electoral justice, constitutional court, political rights, democratic

Abstract

The protection of electoral rights for Indonesian citizen lies at the core of constitutional democracy, serving as both the foundation of political legitimacy and the safeguard of representative governance. The absence of effective judicial remedies for violations of these rights constitutes far more than a procedural deficiency; it is a structural breach in the constitutional order that undermines the integrity of the electoral process and erodes the legitimacy of democratic governance. Lacking a constitutional complaint mechanism, individuals are denied a direct justiciable remedy for violations of their fundamental political rights, leaving those rights vulnerable to diminution through administrative arbitrariness or political instrumentalization. In the Republic of Indonesia, this institutional gap is particularly pronounced. The Constitutional Court’s jurisdiction is narrowly confined to adjudicating disputes over election results and conducting abstract constitutional review, offering no forum to address individual grievances rooted in rights violations. This lacuna constrains accountability, perpetuates structural inequities, and diminishes public confidence in the democratic system. Rectifying this deficiency is therefore not a matter of procedural refinement but a democratic imperative—one that demands reimagining the judiciary’s role as both guardian of constitutional legality and guarantor of meaningful political participation. This article advances the normative argument for recognizing constitutional complaints as an essential mechanism for ensuring electoral justice, employing a normative juridical research approach that emphasizes the examination of constitutional principles and doctrinal interpretations relevant to the safeguarding of electoral rights. It contends that constitutional courts must serve not only as interpreters of constitutional norms but also as institutional guarantors of democratic participation through their adjudicative authority. Drawing on comparative legal experiences, the paper examines how constitutional complaint procedures, when designed with electoral justice in mind, can bridge the gap between formal electoral rules and the substantive protection of political rights. In conclusion, it underscores the urgency of reform in jurisdictions lacking such mechanisms, highlighting the potential for greater accountability, inclusivity, and democratic resilience.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

  • Dayandini HP, Ministry of National Development Planning/National Development Planning Agency

    Dayandini Hastiti Putri, the first author earned her Bachelor of Laws degree in 2023. Her academic interests focus on constitutional law, administrative law, and government policy. Since 2021, she has been actively involved in academic and research activities as a teaching assistant and researcher. In terms of scholarly publications, she published an article in 2025 in Jurnal RechtsVinding, a journal indexed in SINTA 2, entitled “Challenges and Opportunities in the Downstream Development of Mineral and Coal Mining Commodities toward Golden Indonesia 2045: An Evaluation of Law Enforcement and the Administrative Governance of Mining Licensing.” She also published an article in Majalah Hukum Nasional entitled “Parliamentary Threshold and the Future of Multiparty Politics in Indonesia: An Analysis of Constitutional Court Decision No. 116/PUU-XXI/2023” and contributed as the third author of the book Implementation and Evaluation of Campaign Practices in the 2024 Simultaneous Elections. Together with the second author, she co-authored an article published in Majalah Hukum Nasional, Volume 55, Issue 2 (2025), entitled “Toward a New Epistemology of Environmental Law: Recalibrating Regulations for Climate Justice and Sustainability.” She currently serves as a Legislative Drafter at the Ministry of National Development Planning/National Development Planning Agency (Bappenas), Indonesia.

  • Fidelia Febi Valentika, Universitas Diponegoro

    Fidelia Febi Valentika, earned her Bachelor of Laws degree from the Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro, in 2023. During her undergraduate studies, she received a Bank Indonesia Scholarship in 2021, which encouraged her involvement in the Generasi Baru Indonesia (GenBI) Semarang organization, where she served as secretary. After completing her undergraduate degree, she received the Indonesia Endowment Fund for Education (LPDP)-administered Indonesia Education Scholarship (BPI) through the Beasiswa Indonesia Maju scheme in 2023 to pursue a Master of Laws degree at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro, which she completed in 2025. In terms of scholarly publications, she published two articles in 2024 in Jurnal Pembangunan Hukum Indonesia, a journal indexed in SINTA 2. The articles are entitled “Integration of Financial Innovation and Environmental Policy in Carbon Exchanges: A Review of Legal Frameworks and Best Practices in Indonesia” (Volume 6, Issue 3) and “Consumer Protection Principles in the Operation of Non-Bank Foreign Exchange Businesses” (Volume 6, Issue 1). She also contributed to the collaborative book Reflections on and Evaluation of Law Enforcement in the 2024 Elections: From the South Kalimantan Election Supervisory Agency to Indonesia, published in 2024. Together with the first author, she co-authored an article published in Majalah Hukum Nasional, Volume 55, Issue 2 (2025), entitled “Toward a New Epistemology of Environmental Law: Recalibrating Regulations for Climate Justice and Sustainability.” She currently works as a staff member at the Central Java Provincial Government.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-31

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

GUARDIANS OF THE BALLOT: CONSTITUTIONAL COURTS, ELECTORAL RIGHTS, AND THE COMPLAINT PATHWAY TO JUSTICE. (2026). The Journal of Indonesian Constitution and Administrative Law (JICAL), 1(02). https://ojs.kayyismuliajaya.org/index.php/jical/article/view/394